Pirates Opening Day looked more like game 163 of the 2024 season

The Pirates blew a 4-1 lead and lost 5-4 in Miami as the bullpen fell apart. The game looked like a complete replica of 2024. Colin Holderman and David Bednar gave up a combined three runs and Bednar didn't record an out. If Bednar was from somewhere other than here, would he be receiving more criticism?